For socrates the only consideration is whether or not he would be doing the right thing by leaving socrates wants to do no wrong at all crito reminds socrates that he has been done wrong by the jury socrates is not guilty of the crimes he was charged with and is being asked to die crito urges him to leave he does not. At the same time, he admits that no one would intentionally make the people worse so long as he is obliged to live among them from this it follows either that socrates is not making the people worse or he is doing so unintentionally in either case, he is guilty of no crime and ought not be punished obviously, meletus does. Professor cartledge said: there is no denying his bravery, and he could even be seen as an intellectual hero but the idea that socrates himself was not guilty, but executed by mob rule, is wrong by removing him, society had in, athenians' eyes , been cleansed and reaffirmed professor angie hobbs, a. He is also guilty of corrupting the youth the penalty demanded is death this video clip takes us through the trial of socrates, as reported by plato in his apology at the time, plato - one of socrates' students - was 27 years old he was a spectator at the event, not one of the 500 jurors who were all men of. For example at 28a7–9 socrates mentions the threat from meletus and anytus without saying anything about lycon: 'and this it is which will cause my being found guilty, if it is to cause it, not meletus or anytus, but the prejudice and dislike of the many' by following plato's lead to this passage we discover something further. Capital punishment he is accused of corrupting the young and disbelieving in the gods of the city at the trial he is found guilty, and then in jail he accepts the execution even though he has a chance to escape this is the way in which he ends his life furthermore, it is also a fact that at the trial socrates does not behave like.
In any event, the historical accuracy of plato's apology should not be the only question on the reader's mind of equal importance is whether plato's socrates really is guilty of the charges brought against him, whether he is a wholly just and admirable person, whether his manner of living is the one that is most worthwhile (or. The only works of socrates survive through the pen of his student plato, as well as xenophon according to those accounts, socrates supposedly could have escaped athens after he was found guilty by an athenian jury instead, he chose to stay on principle he would abide by the law and apparently. Since the time socrates has gained fame for accepting his death for the charges of corrupting the youth and not believing in the g-d's, scholars, professors, and students of all kinds have argued and debated the truth behind his guilty sentence there are those who believe that socrates was simply guilty,. Socrates was not guilty of treason against athens because his teachings were never intended to oppose fundamental athenian beliefs and values plato was motivated by socrates to education children to be good, democratic students, so socrates was never a disbeliever of athenian democracy on top of.
In 399 bc meletus, a poet, brought a formal accusation against socrates he stated that socrates was guilty of not paying respect to the gods whom the state respects, of introducing new divinities, and of corrupting the young socrates was summoned to appear before a jury of athenian citizens anytus, a powerful. I'm inclined to the view that justice does not exist in a vacuum the fact remains that socrates was tried and found guilty in an athenian court in the absence of any externally valid conception of justice, socrates was found guilty by the method of athenian practice, and insofar as this constituted justice for. 3) socrates is guilty of corrupting the young this charge is a consequence of the other charges 4) socrates does not believe in the gods of the city this charge largely follows from the first charge early societies were theocracies since political power derived from the gods and in many cases political leaders might regard.
The only works of socrates survive through the pen of his student plato, as well as xenophon according to those accounts, socrates supposedly could have escaped athens after he was found guilty by an athenian jury instead, he chose to stay on principle he would abide by the law and apparently didn't even try to. Having been found guilty of corruption and impiety, socrates and the prosecutor suggested sentences for the punishment of his crimes against the city-state of athens expressing surprise at the few votes required for an acquittal, socrates joked that he be punished with free meals at the prytaneum (the city's sacred hearth),. In socrates case, the situation is no different one may be said to be guilty or not of any said crime, but the true measure of guilt or innocence is only as valid as the court structure to which it is subject to therefore, in considering whether socrates is guilty or not, we must keep in mind the societal norms and standards of. Through the centuries, historians have portrayed the 399bc trial as a travesty, with socrates forced to face charges invented by his ignorant fellow citizens he was found guilty of impiety and corrupting the young, sentenced to death, and then required to carry out his own execution by consuming a.
The court votes and finds him guilty: 281 found him guilty, while 221 found innocent ( 35-a) the accuses is now to propose his alternative penalty to death penalty by the indictment socrates says that as he has done so much for the state and for the others, he may deserve some rewards and asks: then what is suitable for. On a day in 399 bc the philosopher socrates stood before a jury of 500 of his fellow athenians accused of refusing to recognize the gods recognized by the state and of corrupting the youth if found guilty his penalty could be death the trial took place in the heart of the city, the jurors seated on wooden benches.
Socrates: guilty or innocent essay 847 words | 4 pages in plato's, the apology of socrates, socrates was accused and on trial for two charges: that he had corrupted the youth of athens with his teachings, and, that he advocated the worship of false gods socrates taught his students to question everything in a thirst for. Plato's apology of socrates3 in an attempt to understand why the athenian dicasts could conceivably have found socrates guilty of the indictment brought against him the indictment read as follows: socrates is guilty of not acknowledging the gods acknowledged by the city and of introducing other new divinities he is also.
Prove that i am not guilty of the charges in meletus' deposition, but this is sufficient (ap 28a) by the end of the cross-examination, then, socrates claims to have proven that he is innocent of corrupting the youth and impiety, and each of the three arguments delivered in the cross-examination is ostensibly a component of a. Once again, socrates interrogation was so powerful meletus couldn't respond socrates informs the court many who had been in the same situation (facing death) have cried and pleaded for their lives socrates states after being found guilty to die in this manner was a blessing he felt there may be a more pleasant place. After socrates had been found guilty of impiety and corrupting the morals of the city's youth, he was next invited to propose a suitable punishment this was a legal tradition in athens and an opportunity for him to show remorse, and hopefully lessen his sentence but asked what sort of punishment he thought he should. After socrates had been found guilty by the narrowish margin of sixty votes, both sides proposed rival penalties for the jurors to choose between no other option was possible his opponents demanded the death penalty socrates himself suggested that he deserved to be maintained at public expense for.